Inky the octopusGet-Inky

Inky Mall OS vs ConsignCloud

ConsignCloud is web-based consignment and mall software with Shopify and Square. Inky Mall OS is a Windows or Mac register that works offline.

What ConsignCloud is for

ConsignCloud describes itself as purpose-built consignment software and POS for resale stores, vendor and antique malls among them. A booth fee comes out of each vendor's balance weekly, biweekly or monthly; shoppers buy from any booth in one transaction; each vendor gets a login to add items, print labels and track sales; and payouts go by ACH from your bank account. It sells online through Shopify or Square, imports your data free, and runs in a browser on a computer or tablet. (Checked on their site, 2026-11-10.)

Where Inky Mall OS is different

Much of the job is shared ground: booths, rent taken out at payout, one receipt across many booths, consignment, payouts and statements, gift certificates, layaway, store credit. The difference is how it runs. Inky Mall OS is a desktop app on the store's own Windows or Mac computer, and one license covers every vendor with no cap; their view from home is free to them on the store's Cloud+. Vendors can set a bottom dollar on an item (selling below one needs a manager or owner PIN) and stock their booth from a phone photo (with Cloud+). Online, Inky goes to the marketplaces: with an Inky online plan, the same items are photographed, written up and priced for eBay and the others.

Side by side

The rows mall owners ask about most, from the same checked data as the full comparison. Each cell links to where we read it.

Yes they say they do itPartial part of it, limit in the noteNo they say they don'tNot stated not stated on their site
Row
Inky Mall OS
Desktop app · Windows and Mac
$99 or $199 up front, then $20/yr; Cloud+ $19.99/mo optionalSource · checked Nov 10
ConsignCloud
Web browser · computer or tablet
$139 to $189/mo per locationSource · checked Nov 10
One receipt across many boothsYesOne receipt across every booth in the cart. Source · checked Nov 10YesOne sale across all booths; each vendor's balance is credited. Source · checked Nov 10
More than one sales-tax rateBy category, item or locationPartialOne rate per store; each Pro location can have its own. No rates by category or item. Source · checked Nov 10YesTax rules by tag or category. Source · checked Nov 10
Rent taken out of payoutsYesRent comes out at payout; any shortfall carries forward. Source · checked Nov 10YesRecurring fee deducted from vendor balance; on Basic plan too. Source · checked Nov 10
Rent charged to the vendor's card or bankOr paid online by the vendorNoRent payments are recorded at the counter; Inky doesn't charge a vendor's card or bank. Source · checked Nov 10NoRent comes out of the balance only; vendors can't be invoiced. Source · checked Nov 10
Floor map of the boothsNoNo floor map. Source · checked Nov 10Not statedNot stated on their site. Source · checked Nov 10
Pay vendors straight to their bank (ACH)NoNo bank (ACH) payouts. Source · checked Nov 10YesFrom the store's bank, $2.50 a payout; US only. Source · checked Nov 10
Vendors check sales from homeYesVendors see their booth from home, with the store's Cloud+; also a PIN view at the counter. Source · checked Nov 10YesVendor Login (Pro plan): own items, sales, balance, labels. Source · checked Nov 10
No per-vendor charge for the portalTo the store or the vendorYesFree to vendors; covered by the store's flat Cloud+, no per-vendor charge. Source · checked Nov 10YesIncluded in Pro ($189/mo/location) up to 1,000 vendors; no per-vendor fee published. Source · checked Nov 10
Keeps ringing sales offlineYesEvery screen keeps working; register sync and the Square reader wait for the internet. Source · checked Nov 10PartialTheir Stripe reader takes cards in an outage; the app itself needs the internet. Source · checked Nov 10
MacYesmacOS 10.15 or later. Source · checked Nov 10YesIn a browser; their print app runs on Mac. Source · checked Nov 10
iPad registerNoNo iPad register. Source · checked Nov 10PartialRuns in a tablet browser; they advise against printing from an iPad. Source · checked Nov 10
Thermal label printersYesZebra (ZPL) and Jadens, Munbyn, Rollo, iDPRT (TSPL), by USB or network on Windows and Mac; no DYMO. Source · checked Nov 11YesDYMO LabelWriter 550, Zebra ZD411/ZD421, TSC TDP-247 guide; Rollo (untested). Source · checked Nov 10
Use any card processor, no extra feeYesAny other card machine works; ring it as a card sale. No fee from Inky. Source · checked Nov 10YesNon-integrated processor allowed on any plan, no extra charge; keyed in separately. Source · checked Nov 10
Their team moves your dataYesPaid human-assisted data move, bought in the app; refunded if the data can't come over. Source · checked Nov 10YesFree; their team imports active accounts and inventory after a test run. Source · checked Nov 10
QuickBooksNoNo QuickBooks connection. Source · checked Nov 10NoNo accounting integration; export sales to Excel and import yourself. Source · checked Nov 10
ShopifyNoNo Shopify connection. Source · checked Nov 10YesTwo-way sync on every plan; gift cards and store credit don't sync. Source · checked Nov 10
Registers share live salesYesUp to 5 registers stay in sync live, with Cloud+. Source · checked Nov 10YesMultiple registers with synced inventory and central reporting. Source · checked Nov 10

It keeps ringing with the internet down

ConsignCloud's help center calls it web-based software that runs in any browser with a Wi-Fi connection. Inky Mall OS is offline-first: when the connection drops, sales, receipts, discounts, gift cards and layaways keep working, and it all catches up when you're back. Only register sync and the Square card reader wait for the internet.

What it costs you to run

ConsignCloud is simple monthly pricing with no long-term contract. Vendor access comes on its Pro plan, priced per location with a vendor cap that Enterprise lifts, and each ACH payout carries a fee. Inky Mall OS is paid for up front, then a small yearly license keeps it running, every vendor included at any number, and Cloud+ (registers in sync, vendors checking their booth from home, the Square reader) is a flat monthly add-on rather than a charge per head.

That shape is deliberate. We came up in resale ourselves and know how thin the margins are, so we would rather the register never became the line on your P&L that worries you: it's paid for up front, then a small yearly license keeps it running.

Over a few years that's a different shape of bill, so do the sums with today's numbers. Theirs are on their site; ours are on our Inky Mall OS pricing page.

The software over 1, 3 and 5 years

One store · 2 registers · 50 vendors · in sync · vendor portal. Published prices only, each with its source and date; card fees, hardware and sales tax are extra.

Product and planYear 13 years5 years
Inky Mall OS + Cloud+Core $99 up front, $20 a year from year 2, Cloud+ $19.99/moCard fees: Square's, if you use its readerSource · checked Nov 10$338.88$858.64$1,378.40
ConsignCloudPro $189/mo per locationSource · checked Nov 10$2,268$6,804$11,340
Inky Mall OS, no Cloud+Core $99 up front, then $20 a year to keep the license activeDoesn't cover registers sharing sales or vendors checking from home (both need Cloud+)Source · checked Nov 10$99$139$179
Inky Mall OS + Cloud+Core $99 up front, $20 a year from year 2, Cloud+ $19.99/moCard fees: Square's, if you use its readerSource · checked Nov 10
Year 1$338.88
3 years$858.64
5 years$1,378.40
ConsignCloudPro $189/mo per locationSource · checked Nov 10
Year 1$2,268
3 years$6,804
5 years$11,340
Inky Mall OS, no Cloud+Core $99 up front, then $20 a year to keep the license activeDoesn't cover registers sharing sales or vendors checking from home (both need Cloud+)Source · checked Nov 10
Year 1$99
3 years$139
5 years$179
Change the numbers in the cost calculator

Who should pick which

Pick ConsignCloud if you want a Shopify or Square store selling the same stock, ACH payouts to vendors, a counter that runs in a browser on a computer or tablet, or a free import with their team's help. ConsignCloud does those today, by its own description; Inky Mall OS doesn't. On QuickBooks, neither of us connects today: ConsignCloud's help center says it has no accounting integration yet.

Pick Inky Mall OS if the counter has to keep working with the internet down; if you want the register on the Windows or Mac computer you already have; if one license should cover every vendor, with their view from home free to them; or if you want bottom dollars kept at the register and booths stocked from a phone photo.

The honest difference

ConsignCloud says thousands of resellers use it, and it brings real connections: Shopify, Square, Stripe, ACH payouts, a free import. That head start is the one thing Inky can't hand you today. What Inky can hand you is a register on the computer itself, Windows or Mac, that keeps every screen working when the Wi-Fi drops and covers every vendor on one license, whether you have six booths or six hundred. And with an Inky online plan, the same stock is photographed, written up and priced for eBay and the others. Free for 30 days — judge it on your own counter.

ConsignCloud's current plans and features are on their own site — always check there rather than trusting a comparison page to stay current. Inky's are on our Inky Mall OS pricing page.

The real comparison is a day at your counter

Ring a real day of sales on the free 30-day trial. That's the whole pitch.

30-day trial, no card.

All comparisons